A Whisper of Aids Rhetorical Analysis Paper

Shayan Momin Momin 1 Mr. Pople AP English III, Period 7 12 October 2012 Rhetorical Analysis of A whispering of AIDS In 1891, Voltairine de Cleyre wrote The philosophical system of Selfishness and Metaphysical Ethics, critiquing the selfish and egoistic lookout of indian lodge. This same mindset is critiqued by bloody shame fisher cat in A Whisper of AIDS. She uses rationall(a)y emotional elaborateness in order to criticize this self-ism that exists in the world. fisherman begins by speaking of the non-existent impacts of movements that shoot assay to raise aw atomic number 18ness just approximately AIDS.She utilizes the word despite in succeeding(prenominal) phrases to show that despite science and investigate and good intentions, nothing evidentiary has occurred because the epiphytotic is still winning. by dint of her customs duty of repetition, it is inferable that partnership has ignored these efforts due to the focus of view that was scorched by de Cleyre. This ignorance from the public reveals how deeply rooted this self-ism is in our society. And to extend her period even further, she says that the White House has attempted to try to raise aw atomic number 18ness about AIDS.Her reference to the government further exposes the self-possession of society to change their selfish itinerary of life. She tries to say that even with the government button for this cause, the public still refuses to take action. barely even the government isnt doing much. Fisher mentions the campaign slogans and hopeful promises that were made by the government with a sarcastic t hotshot. This implies that the utterer believes that even our federal government has a mindset of selfishness. however this is only the start out of her attack on society. Momin 2She goes on to whang society for the magnitude of the viruss impacts. She says that by ignoring the virus and the state abnormal by it, society has helped the virus along and that we harbor killed i ndividually other with our ignorance, our prejudice, and our silence. Her usage of a list explains in what slipway society has committed such a crime. And all of this is due to the existence of a mindset that promotes self-centration, a mindset that calls for the ignorance of all others who coexist with you. The connotation of killed has a doubling effect.First, its negative connotation creates an image in iodins head of a mob of people destroying one another. It represents how horrendous the aftermath of the virus has been. The second effect, one that is deeper, and somewhat hidden, is that the word killed implies the killing of open-mindedness and selflessness. It shows how people detriment severally other, knock each other down, and even kill each other for their own selfish desires. In this case, society has ignored the AIDS virus because they have the thought that If I enduret have it, I shouldnt care about it.This kind of view has lay ruin for the victims of this virus , who have been hurt even more due to the ignorance of society towards such a major problem. Fisher refers to empirics in order to prove the prejudicious effects of having a selfish society. She speaks of how her grandfather had heard the Pastor Niemoeller say that when the Nazis came after the Jews, he didnt protest because he wasnt a Jew. When the Nazis came after the handle Unionists, the pastor did not protest because he wasnt a Trade Unionist. But when the Nazis came after the pastor, there was no one left to protest.The parallelism use here helps to better define the impacts of a self-minded society, supporting the speakers of import purpose which is to critique the self-ism that exists today. This quote is significant in another way as well. The way the pastor reacted to the Nazi encroachment is the same way people are reacting Momin 3 to the AIDS and HIV virus. They are mirror reflections of each other. It shows that people bequeath only conduct when they are victimize d. When this happened to the pastor, he then realized his mistake. But in this case, if people will only learn through victimization, the result would be catastrophic.Fisher says how a million are infected in a flash if this is what is to happen, billions will be exposed to the virus. Through this foreshadowing, the author is able to convince the lector that self-centration will lead to our demise. Unless we become aware. bloody shame Fishers critiquing of societys selfishness and self-mindedness makes the reader aware of the dangers of having such a mindset. Her purpose is to point out that in order to help raise sensory faculty of HIV we must first unloose ourselves of such a malignant way of thinking.